Canadian General Misses Out on NATO Leadership Role

Despite support from the federal government, Canada’s chief of defence staff has lost the election to become the next chair of the NATO Military Committee, which serves as the top military authority for the alliance and advises its political leaders.

Gen. Jennie Carignan was in competition with her German counterpart, Gen. Carsten Breuer, for this role. Ultimately, senior military leaders from NATO’s 32 member countries chose Breuer during a secret ballot held on Saturday.

The announcement came via social media from the current chair, Italian Admiral Giuseppe Cavo Dragone, who extended his congratulations to Breuer on his election.

“Your operational judgement, your deep familiarity with this alliance and your leadership of the German Armed Forces will serve NATO well,” Dragone said.

A Canadian hasn’t held this position in nearly twenty years – the last was retired general Ray Henault from 2005 to 2008. If she had won, Carignan would have made history as the first woman to lead the Military Committee in its 77-year existence.

In a statement shared on social media, Carignan congratulated Breuer and expressed that “it was an honour to stand as a candidate and to engage with my fellow Allied Chiefs of Defence throughout this process.”

“There is important work ahead for our Alliance, and I know General Breuer will bring strong leadership to his new role. I deeply value the close relationship we have built and look forward to continuing to work together on our NATO initiatives,” Carignan added.

Speaking with reporters outside a Liberal caucus retreat in Ottawa on Saturday afternoon, Defence Minister David Mc Guinty expressed pride in Carignan’s candidacy for Canada. He noted that they don’t know how each country voted.

“The important thing is that Gen. Carignan will continue to serve alongside her colleagues – all 31 other chiefs of defence in the alliance. It’s a very important contribution we’re making,” Mc Guinty said.

“Gen. Carignan is doing a phenomenal job.”

Possible U. S. Challenges for Carignan’s Appointment

Experts who previously spoke with indicated that U. S. President Donald Trump could pose a challenge for Carignan’s chances – especially following Prime Minister Mark Carney’s announcement about strengthening Canada’s ties with Europe.

“Trump is not going to let a Canadian or a woman be head of the military committee if anybody around him has paid attention,” said Steven Saideman, a defense expert at Carleton University who has extensively covered NATO issues.

Breuer is a 61-year-old army officer known as “the chancellor’s general” after then-German chancellor Olaf Scholz appointed him to lead a crisis committee managing Germany’s response during COVID-19 in 2021 and 2022.

He began his career in an air defense unit within Bundeswehr back in 1984 and later attended both U. S. general staff college at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, and German general staff training in Hamburg.

In 2014, Breuer worked with NATO’s International Security Assistance Force based in Kabul during their operations there.

Dragone stated on social media that Breuer will assume office come July 2027.

Source link