NP CommentLetters
Readers touch upon Donald Trump’s 51st state joke, the sanctity of a navy marching tune, the docs’ scarcity, the postal strike and extra
Printed Dec 08, 2024 • Final up to date 2 hours in the past • 10 minute learn
. .
A picture posted to Donald Trump’s Reality Social account on Dec. 3, 2024, with the caption: “Oh Canada!” Photograph by Reality Social
Article content material
‘A small price to pay for the economic benefits’
Article content material
Article content material
Re: FIRST READING: Why the Individuals would by no means, ever let Canada grow to be a state — Tristin Hopper, Dec. 4; and Trump’s ’51st state’ remark has Trudeau, premiers operating in numerous instructions — Tasha Kheiriddin, Dec. 3
At his latest assembly with our prime minister, President-elect Donald Trump mused that Canada might grow to be the 51st state. Let’s take into account the attainable advantages.
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS
Benefit from the newest native, nationwide and worldwide information.
Unique articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, particular version NP Platformed and First Studying newsletters and digital occasions.Limitless on-line entry to Ontario Chronicle and 15 information websites with one account. Ontario Chronicle ePaper, an digital duplicate of the print version to view on any gadget, share and touch upon.Each day puzzles together with the New York Instances Crossword.Assist native journalism.
SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE ARTICLES
Benefit from the newest native, nationwide and worldwide information.
Unique articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, particular version NP Platformed and First Studying newsletters and digital occasions.Limitless on-line entry to Ontario Chronicle and 15 information websites with one account. Ontario Chronicle ePaper, an digital duplicate of the print version to view on any gadget, share and touch upon.Each day puzzles together with the New York Instances Crossword.Assist native journalism.
.
….
.
.
Entry articles from throughout Canada with one accountShare your ideas and be a part of the dialog within the commentsEnjoy further articles per monthGet e mail updates out of your favorite authors
Do not have an account? Create Account
or
Register with out password New , a brand new method to login
Article content material
Underneath the American taxation system, Canadians would get to maintain extra of their hard-earned money (no GST holidays wanted).
We might lastly have a frontrunner who would unwaveringly assist the one democracy within the Center East (and never UNRWA) in opposition to the terrorist bullies who battle for Israel’s demise, and a frontrunner who would stand as much as the harmful despots in Russia, China and North Korea and shackle Iran’s nuclear aspirations. Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu could be welcomed with out concern of being arrested. (The U.S. isn’t a member of the Worldwide Legal Courtroom.)
Our armed forces would proudly serve with a technologically-advanced and well-funded navy.
And our ever-falling loonie could be exchanged for the buck, which is presently value Cdn $1.40.
If it means not having hashish outlets on each road nook, that’s a small value to pay for the financial advantages that will accrue to the typical Canadian household.
Susan Silverman, Toronto
Canada changing into the 51st U.S. state is a good concept. Given its inhabitants of just about 40 million, Canada would have a big block of votes within the electoral school and due to this fact a big say in choosing the president. There could be no worries about tariffs on exports to the U.S., which might permit our economic system to flourish. There could be no extra worries in regards to the safety of the border, and the prices related to it. And our navy would lastly be well-equipped with trendy armament.
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
It’s certainly meals for thought, laced with maple syrup.
Roger Cyr, Victoria, B.C.
Stand as much as Donald Trump
Re: Trump is defaming Canada — Conrad Black, Nov. 30
Tariffs make for unusual bedfellows, as I discover myself agreeing with Conrad Black, a distinguished Canadian apologist for Donald Trump’s transactional politics, regardless of its contradictions with ethical and authorized values. On this occasion, nevertheless, all Canadians ought to unite with Black, who rightly views Trump’s threatened 25 per cent tariffs on us as a “slur,” and with Doug Ford, who finds them “insulting.” Black is appropriate: when Trump’s tariffs slap us within the face and defame us, then that calls for a quintessentially Canadian response: well mannered, principled, and powerfully resolute defence.
Canada’s historical past has heritage moments of standing as much as bullies. Loyalists got here right here figuring out with our impartial path separate from America. From Conservative John Diefenbaker’s steadfast independence in opposition to strain from JFK to Liberals like Pierre Trudeau’s candid disagreement with Richard Nixon over Vietnam and prime minister Jean Chrétien’s refusal to hitch the Iraq Battle — all our events have demonstrated our nationwide spine.
Platformed
Article content material
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
Thus Trump’s “America First” rhetoric ought to meet its match in Canada’s quiet energy. We’re the biggest international vitality provider to the U.S. and our bilateral commerce exceeds $960 billion. Translation? We’re not simply neighbours — we’re important companions.
Canadians, unite. Resist. Persist. Political partisanship is irrelevant when our nationwide dignity and financial survival are at stake. Positively sturdy and free, not like Trump’s me-ism, we’ll usually stand on guard for the ideas of mutual respect.
Tony D’Andrea, Toronto
Don’t count on new border helicopters anytime quickly
Re: Liberals conscious of RCMP numbers wanted to spice up border safety — Stephanie Taylor, Dec. 3
Underneath urging from Donald Trump, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has agreed to purchase extra helicopters for the RCMP to patrol the border. Trump is probably not conscious, however the Trudeau Liberals are the kings of the Pathetic Procurement Patsies. Their tools buy failures make their passport places of work appear to be they run with McDonald’s effectivity. Now Trudeau might attempt to purchase used helicopters to hurry up the acquisition, identical to a earlier Liberal authorities bought previous diesel-electric submarines that the British Navy didn’t need anymore. Sadly, a number of crewmen have been injured preventing {an electrical} hearth aboard considered one of them, the Chicoutimi, and submariner Lt. Chris Saunders died.
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
So each time these helicopters arrive, count on that Trudeau’s Liberals will completely screw up the acquisition and put the “hell” in helicopters.
Chris Robertson, Stony Plain, Alta.
Preserve enjoying the ‘Heart of Oak’
Re: Royal Canadian Navy considers dropping conventional marching tune over range points — Chris Lambie, Nov. 22
As a Tenth-generation Canadian — whose grandfather, the Hon. Louis Philippe Brodeur, in 1910 launched the Naval Service Act, which created the Royal Canadian Navy, and whose father, Rear Admiral Victor Gabriel Brodeur, commanded Canada’s Pacific Coast throughout World Battle II, and who myself retired in 1988 as a Vice-Admiral and Canada’s Deputy Chief of the Defence Employees — I’ve witnessed the Royal Canadian Navy marching to (and being honoured by) “Heart of Oak” in lots of international locations.
I additionally wish to level out that lots of of 1000’s of naval Canadians have cherished that anthem, (and gained energy, unity and braveness from it), again when Canada had the third largest navy within the Second World Battle, and that 1000’s of these Canadians died in sea battles then and subsequently.
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
It’s my very agency perception that nobody serving in the present day, and particularly not the Canadian authorities, which has allowed the Royal Canadian Navy to say no to twenty third place on the planet’s navies, has earned, or owns, the precise to take away or modify Coronary heart of Oak. Fairly than waste cash on such mindless idiocy, let Canada take each speedy motion to strengthen our navy in these parlous instances.
Nigel Brodeur, Vice-Admiral (retired)
A slippery slope for Confederation
Re: Quebec has a brand new autonomy playbook — Antoine Trépanier, Nov. 27
Shouldn’t there be just one structure on this nation? Quebec appears to be realizing separation with out really separating. If Quebec has its personal structure, then different provinces will certainly observe go well with. Can you’ve separate de facto international locations inside one nation? This may very well be a slippery slope, and theoretically the top of Canadian federation. Canada is a particularly versatile nation, however the political elasticity can solely stretch thus far.
Douglas Cornish, Ottawa
‘Absolutism has gained ascendency over truth’
Re: Trudeau enjoying with hearth supporting false charges of deeply flawed ICC — Joe Oliver, Nov. 27
Commercial 7
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
The violent demonstrations we have now been experiencing in Canada present clear proof that there’s something flawed with the ideology of multiculturalism. I say “ideology,” as a result of this degree of violence was not alleged to occur, in keeping with Justin Trudeau’s idealistic worldview, which conveniently glosses over the truth that a few of the world’s cultures are dedicated to absolutist dogmas that search to destroy the ideas of others, and even any chance of truthfulness elsewhere.
Inside a democracy, we don’t say human people at all times know what’s true, or that they might by no means be flawed, or that self-expression is invariably proper, however there are some cultures that do make these claims.
{That a} specific tradition may be picked on in extreme and violent methods — as has been the case with the Jews in Canada — is a transparent indication that absolutism has gained ascendency over fact — a depravity that has already killed thousands and thousands all through historical past and now desolates democracy in Canada.
Gordon Watson, Rocky Mountain Home, Alta.
Extra, not fewer docs wanted
Commercial 8
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
Re: Jewish docs take into account fleeing Canada amid rising charges of antisemitism of their occupation — Ari David Blaff, Dec. 4; and Canada’s household physician scarcity: 10 million will quickly lack entry to major care — Sharon Kirkey, Feb. 16
The alarming article relating to Jewish docs pondering of leaving Canada for a safer surroundings ought to give our political masters one thing to chew on. By not nipping the ugliness of antisemitism within the bud when it first raised its vile head on our streets and in our universities, they’ve allowed it to take root. They may have been complicit in making our well being providers even worse than they already have been if our Jewish mates and neighbours pack up and go away. The cowardice of the authorities in Canada is a nationwide shame.
Ted Mead, Winchester, Ont.
At Dalhousie College in Halifax, the tutoring payment for first yr medication mixed with different associated charges is $26,260, whereas dentistry is $57,840 — not together with dwelling bills. In Europe, there are at the least 22 international locations with free college tuition out there for all residents.
At present in Nova Scotia there are over 160,000 individuals with out a household doctor, which is a demise sentence for a lot of as a result of early prognosis and therapy are important in lots of ailments.
Commercial 9
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
There isn’t a legitimate motive for Canadians to not have entry to a free college training besides that our spending priorities as a nation are misguided. Canadians spend billions for highway development however significantly much less on public transportation (which needs to be free to make use of), and thousands and thousands housing unlawful immigrants whereas all however ignoring the nation’s estimated 150,00 to 300,000 freezing, hungry and sick homeless; impoverished Canadians who’re pressured to make use of meals banks (Meals Banks Canada reported greater than two million visits to meals banks in March, a file); and the one in 5 youngsters who report typically going to highschool or mattress hungry.
A overview of our priorities is so as.
Morris Givner, Halifax
Feds must intervene in postal strike
Re: Canada Publish strike: Stress rises on the federal authorities to intervene — Dec. 4
Although Canada Publish is an “independent” Crown company, it offers a authorities service, significantly to small companies and to rural communities. As such, the federal authorities must become involved to resolve the continued strike. If Labour Minister Steven MacKinnon continues to imagine there isn’t a position for him to play, then the Liberal authorities must get out of the way in which and privatize Canada Publish in order that {the marketplace} can repair what ails the company.
Commercial 10
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
Paul Clarry, Aurora, Ont.
Really useful from Editorial
Letters: Bribing taxpayers with their very own cash
Letters: The ‘Eagle Man’ has crash-landed. About time, too
Joseph ‘Beausoleil’ Broussard was an Acadian hero
Re: Parks Canada celebrates a settler scalper, however slanders Sir John A. — Jamie Sarkonak, Nov. 25
As an eighth-generation descendant and biographer of Joseph “Beausoleil” Broussard (Acadian Redemption, 2005), I felt compelled to reply to Jamie Sarkonak’s column.
In keeping with historical past, an eyewitness positioned Broussard on the scene of the 1751 assault in Dartmouth, N.S., which resulted within the scalping of settlers. In his in depth analysis, Canadian/Acadian archivist and historian Ronnie-Gilles LeBlanc has given particular consideration to the 1749 and 1751 Dartmouth assaults and located nothing to show that Broussard perpetrated these acts — as an alternative, it was probably Abenaki and Iroquois warriors who had been pushed off their lands by New England settlers and who have been searching for revenge.
Sarkonak failed to say the atrocities dedicated by British authorities in opposition to the Acadian inhabitants, together with mass deportations (1755 to 1763) that precipitated as many as 5,000 Acadian deaths. Broussard is taken into account a hero as a result of he fought tirelessly to defend his countrymen earlier than, throughout and after they have been loaded on ships, their houses have been burned, and their livestock and crops destroyed by British forces. Lots of of these not deported died of hunger and illness in refugee camps at Miramichi and close to present-day Campbellton, N.B.
Commercial 11
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
In 1765, Broussard led his countrymen out of exile from prisons in Halifax to a brand new homeland in Louisiana the place in the present day’s “Cajuns” owe him a deep debt of gratitude for transplanting our distinctive tradition on the Gulf of Mexico. Many others — who have been scattered the world over, from British prisons to the Falkland Islands, or who drowned at sea — weren’t so lucky.
In response to a authorized petition I launched in 1990, the Royal Proclamation of 2003 introduced symbolic closure to this centuries-long debate. Whereas recognizing the wrongs dedicated, Queen Elizabeth II established July 28 as an annual Day of Commemoration of the Nice Upheaval. As a part of this closure, the latest historic recognition of Beausoleil Broussard by Parks Canada and others needs to be extensively applauded.
Warren A. Perrin, Chairman, Acadian Museum Erath, La.
An outline of Beausoleil Broussard by the artist Herb Roe. Photograph by Courtesy of the Acadian Museum of Erath, La.
Ruffling feathers over provide administration
Re: Trump 2.0 will power us to resolve vital issues we’ve been ducking — Joe Oliver, Nov. 21
Whereas Joe Oliver has quite a bit to say on the Canada-U.S. dynamic, his feedback on provide administration have “ruffled our feathers.” Canada will definitely must discover a new steadiness in its relationship with our neighbour to the south; nevertheless, it shouldn’t be on the expense of our meals safety. Suggesting that it will be in Canada’s greatest curiosity to eradicate insurance policies and instruments that guarantee we have now dependable entry to staple meals objects and rely extra on imports is solely irresponsible. Have we not discovered our lesson from COVID? Claims that eliminating provide administration would decrease the costs of dairy, poultry and eggs are unfounded. A former finance minister should know there’s a vital distinction between farmgate and retail costs. Farmers don’t set retail costs.
Commercial 12
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
Provide administration is a core a part of the muse that enables our nation to flourish — it helps rural financial exercise, maintains jobs in cities and delivers the homegrown meals that Canadians need. With more and more unstable world markets, rising geopolitical tensions and local weather change, provide administration brings stability to meals manufacturing right here.
David Wiens, Dairy Farmers of Canada; Roger Pelissero, Egg Farmers of Canada; Tim Klompmaker, Hen Farmers of Canada; Darren Ference, Turkey Farmers of Canada; Brian Bilkes, Canadian Hatching Egg Producers
Ontario Chronicle and Ontario Chronicle welcome letters to the editor (200 phrases or fewer). Please embody your title, tackle and daytime telephone quantity. Electronic mail [email protected]. Letters could also be edited for size or readability.
Article content material
Share this text in your social community
