NewsCanadaCanadian PoliticsWorldIsrael & Center East
Selena Robinson says progressive events are unwisely aligning themselves with conservative Muslim teams which are anti-Israel
Revealed Jan 01, 2025 • Final up to date 10 hours in the past • 9 minute learn
. .
Selena Robinson stepped down as post-secondary training minister on Feb. 7, and by March was sitting as an unbiased. She didn’t search re-election in October. Photograph by Jason Payne /PNG
Article content material
It has been a most tough yr for Selina Robinson, who was ousted from B.C.’s NDP cupboard for her feedback throughout a discussion board on Israel. She says she had lengthy identified the NDP had an antisemitism downside however has turn out to be estranged from her progressive friends since Hamas’s October 7, 2023, assaults on Israel.
Robinson’s feedback got here throughout an internet panel dialogue hosted by B’nai Brith Canada on Jan. 30. She referred to the territory on which the fashionable state of Israel was based as “a crappy piece of land with nothing on it — you know, there were several hundred thousand people but other than that, it didn’t produce an economy. It couldn’t grow things; it didn’t have anything on it.”
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS
Benefit from the newest native, nationwide and worldwide information.
Unique articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, particular version NP Platformed and First Studying newsletters and digital occasions.Limitless on-line entry to Ontario Chronicle and 15 information websites with one account. Ontario Chronicle ePaper, an digital duplicate of the print version to view on any system, share and touch upon.Each day puzzles together with the New York Instances Crossword.Help native journalism.
SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE ARTICLES
Benefit from the newest native, nationwide and worldwide information.
Unique articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, particular version NP Platformed and First Studying newsletters and digital occasions.Limitless on-line entry to Ontario Chronicle and 15 information websites with one account. Ontario Chronicle ePaper, an digital duplicate of the print version to view on any system, share and touch upon.Each day puzzles together with the New York Instances Crossword.Help native journalism.
.
….
.
.
Entry articles from throughout Canada with one accountShare your ideas and be a part of the dialog within the commentsEnjoy further articles per monthGet electronic mail updates out of your favorite authors
Haven’t got an account? Create Account
or
Sign up with out password New , a brand new strategy to login
Article content material
Her remarks sparked widespread backlash, with pro-Palestinian teams and others calling for her resignation. She issued a number of apologies and provided to take anti-Islamophobia coaching, however Premier David Eby condemned her feedback as divisive.
She stepped down as post-secondary training minister on Feb. 7, and by March was sitting as an unbiased. She didn’t search re-election in October.
She’s again with a memoir, Reality Be Instructed, launched on Dec. 18.
In it, she expresses disappointment in her fellow NDP authorities members for his or her lack of assist when she confronted assaults as a result of her Jewish id. Most distressing, she says, was the entire absence of vocal assist from her colleagues within the face of racist behaviour, intimidation ways and threats. She spoke to Dave Gordon:
What are your emotions in direction of the New Democrats at present?
I at all times used to say, Jewish values are New Democrat values. And I nonetheless consider that, however what I’m seeing is that New Democrats are contradicting their very own values. They’ve turn out to be very unprogressive, significantly the federal get together, and their strategy to the battle in Israel and the Center East is so one-sided. And the feedback that I see are so antisemitic. I’m positive that Jack Layton is popping over in his grave. Tom Mulcair has spoken out about it, the expansion in antisemitism. He was in a position to shut down this stage of hatred and vitriol in direction of Jews. And so I need voters to concentrate to who they’re voting for, as a result of I don’t consider that at present’s New Democrats characterize progressive values.
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
I’m actually hoping that the ebook invitations individuals to contemplate methods through which the progressive motion, which I contemplate myself a part of, is inconsistent with regards to Jews.
Is it your perception the New Democrats are rising antisemitism in Canada?
Completely proper. So that is coming for years. This isn’t new. I’ve seen it rising over time, amongst excessive voices amongst progressives, and so they have turn out to be mainstream inside progressive circles.
We’re seeing it now in union management specifically, and it’s so unprogressive. They don’t take heed to Jewish voices. The primary lesson in racism is take heed to those that are most impacted, however Jewish voices are fully silenced and drowned out.
So what we’re seeing amongst leftist politics and excessive voices, they’re very hateful and really harmful. I additionally see simply politically, there’s a stage of pandering to extremist voices, that’s I feel reprehensible.
Because of this, the management of progressive federal events, provincial events, are aligning themselves with conservative Muslim teams which are anti-Israel.
You argue that you just have been introduced down not by the “crappy piece of land,” however since you have been Jewish. Are you able to elaborate?
Channel Israel
!
Article content material
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
So I name myself the “Jew and the crew.” In authorities underneath John Horgan’s management, after which underneath David Eby’s management, if there was a difficulty within the Jewish group, everybody got here to me to deal with it.
I grew up within the Jewish group and linked with all of the synagogues. I do know the Jewish management.
There’d be questions within the legislature across the adopting of the IHRA definition of antisemitism. And everybody in cupboard would flip to Selina to reply this query. They usually needed me to — David Eby, the home leaders. I’d do a very good job and I knew they have been happy. If there was a Holocaust memorial of some variety, it was at all times “Selina, are we talking to the right people? Are we engaging?”
So I used to be the Jew and the crew, the marketing consultant, so to talk. So once I was the minister for post-secondary training, and antisemitism was on the rise, we have been seeing it on all of our campuses. I used to be invited to talk on a panel about that. In fact, I ought to talk about that. I’m Jewish, and so I really feel what the Jewish group is feeling on campus.
However I’m additionally the minister for post-secondary training, and so had tons to say about what we have been seeing on campus. And once I mentioned these 4 fateful phrases, “crappy piece of land,” what the context of that was, that I used to be already being recognized by protesters months earlier. They have been already attacking me on social media, partly as a result of I’m Jewish, and partly as a result of I principally mentioned that professors who’re actively antisemitic, that their phrases are unsuitable and abhorrent. And celebrating the bloodbath of Israelis and Jews on October 7 is disgusting. I used to be focused for that.
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
After I mentioned these phrases and it turned public, the premier’s first response to me was, “don’t worry about it. Happens to the best of us.” After which 4 days later, he was telling me that I needed to resign. I’m fairly assured it was as a result of I’m a Jew, and never as a result of I used to be a nasty minister. I feel I used to be a rattling good minister in each file that I’ve had. I used to be fired as a result of I used to be making a little bit of a shit storm, I feel, for the premier, and he didn’t like that.
The left-leaning extremists needed me gone, and it was performed to make life simpler. That’s how I see it. Different individuals suppose that the premier’s antisemitic. Individuals can suppose what they need. They’d must ask him.
What have been your colleagues’ responses?
My coronary heart is so damaged, as a result of the those that I labored with, and for, to create one thing higher right here in British Columbia, they have been so silent when individuals have been calling for loss of life to Jews.
The teachings of the Holocaust and the teachings of any injustice is just not as a lot the perpetrators, however as those that are the bystander, and that has been probably the most heartbreaking factor for me.
I believed, “Where are you?” You stood with me, and also you stood with the Jewish group, on Holocaust Memorial Day. You mentioned, “Never again.” You posted footage on social media concerning the Jewish individuals; you probably did all the precise issues. And when it’s right here, when it’s stay, and once I’m shamed and afraid, you’re afraid to talk? That’s scary.
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
I used to be fairly devastated, so I didn’t take heed to media. However in writing the ebook, I went again to previous media, and the issues that the premier selected to say about me have been very disappointing. He talked about, “deep wounds” that I created for individuals, and the way divisive I used to be. It made it appear to be I used to be evil incarnate. That’s what it felt wish to me.
I used to be simply shocked that the premier would say these issues about me, after figuring out me, working with me, relying on me to ship on many issues that I’ve delivered on, after which to recommend that I had “deep work to do.”
The “deep work” is basically concerning the work that I feel New Democrats throughout this nation must do.
I feel the New Democrats have misplaced their method. They’re partaking in very unprogressive methods. The Jewish group is saying, “we are frightened.” Synagogues are being firebombed, faculties are being shot at. And the NDP is supporting these items, “Zionism is racism.” And we’re saying, “we have a right to have a national homeland, just like everybody else.”
So if we actually need peace, if we actually say that we wish to carry individuals collectively, then you definately carry individuals collectively. How can we have interaction in dialogue collectively, in order that we will ensure that Palestinians do get a greater life for themselves within the area? Demonizing Israel isn’t the way you do it. It simply isn’t. And progressives are partaking in demonizing Israel, and by extension, they’re demonizing Jews. You’ll be able to’t separate Israel from Jews. You simply can’t, unattainable.
Commercial 7
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
Why’d you write the ebook?
There’s so few Jews on the planet. There’s so few Jews in British Columbia, most individuals will undergo life by no means figuring out a Jew. And so I needed to create a spot the place individuals can maybe get their questions answered.
One of many issues that occurred after I used to be fired, simply earlier than I give up caucus, one in all my New Democrat colleagues got here by my workplace to ask some administrative questions, and she or he noticed that I used to be fairly damage. So she mentioned one thing alongside the strains of “I don’t really know any Jews.” She lives in rural British Columbia. I believed, “we’ve been colleagues for four years, and you never asked me a question about being a Jew. Like, I’m right here.”
She saved saying, “I don’t understand the relationship with Israel,” and I’m considering, “You’ve never once come to say you didn’t understand something.”
I needed to create one thing that may permit these of us to learn slightly bit extra about how I used to be sitting contained in the legislature, and there’s a mob of individuals waving flags of terrorist organizations which have simply murdered 1000’s of individuals as a result of they have been Jews, and so they’re yelling “Intifada,” and actually I hear “death to Jews.” I need them to know how painful that was for me and for all Jews. No one got here to see if I used to be OK. No one. So I need them to get the lesson that they failed, and they’re failing the Jewish group.
Commercial 8
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
My values haven’t modified. The left’s values are damaged; their values aren’t constant. They aren’t dwelling as much as the values they proclaim to have. There’s a minority group, Jews, afraid in your group, and you might be silent, since you’re afraid to upend your quote-unquote supporters.
Your ideas on how the difficulty of Israel has turn out to be an obsession with sure unions?
Watch what (Ontario CUPE chief) Fred Hahn is saying. I reached out to my CUPE buddies, very robust supporters of mine. CUPE management labored on my campaigns. They principally mentioned “it’s not our problem.” Like, are you kidding me? Hahn’s celebrating the loss of life of Jews, and also you suppose it’s not your downside?
My grandfather helped construct the union motion in Montreal, and now you’re abandoning him and me. What’s unsuitable with you?
What do you hear Jewish New Democrats saying about their get together?
There’s been a gaggle of Jewish progressives for the final, I’d say, three to 5 years, poking away on the federal New Democrats to say “You’re getting it wrong. Your obsession with Israel is problematic.” Israel is just not an ideal nation, but it surely’s a democracy, and all you’re doing is attacking it. You’re attacking it greater than you assault China, North Korea, Russia, Syria, Iran. You assault Israel greater than all the opposite nations put collectively, and it’s an obsession, and it’s unsuitable, and it’s antisemitic, and so they don’t see it, and that’s the issue.
Commercial 9
This commercial has not loaded but, however your article continues beneath.
Article content material
I’ve been receiving letters from many individuals who assist New Democrats in British Columbia, and the federal get together, and telling me they’re silenced concerning the ladies’s rapes, or they get informed October 7 by no means occurred. They’re horrified.
Then (they) decide me on a “crappy piece of land” — which it was, as a result of it had no pure assets. However I didn’t say something unsuitable, and I used to be attacked as if what I mentioned was a lie.
Any given federal New Democrat has mentioned far, far worse. You get into the double normal. The hatred coming from my get together — the variety of occasions my ex-colleagues have needed to apologize to the Jewish group for misusing the Holocaust as a reference. However the apologies are ridiculous.
This interview has been edited for brevity.
Advisable from Editorial
Selina Robinson: We owe it to Jewish college students to place Canada’s hate legal guidelines to the take a look at in court docket
Selina Robinson: NDP’s cynical ploy to achieve Muslim votes by championing the Palestinian trigger
Our web site is the place for the most recent breaking information, unique scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and join our every day publication, Posted, right here.
Article content material
Share this text in your social community
